Metaphorical Feedback Sessions

Purpose

This advanced communication exercise helps delegates explore how to deliver feedback and insight indirectly but meaningfully, using metaphor, analogy or parable. The metaphorical feedback encourages subtlety, empathy and depth in communication. It builds skill in emotional intelligence, reflective communication. It is particularly useful in coaching, leadership development, team reflection and emotionally charged situations. In such situations literal advice may be resisted, but imagery can cut through to truth in a gentler way. It can often bypass defensiveness and provoke deeper understanding.

Objective

Working in pairs, delegates share a real-life challenge and receive feedback that is entirely metaphorical, as a symbol, fable, or analogy. This teaches them to listen for deeper themes and deliver constructive input in a more creative, reflective and emotionally intelligent way.

What You Need

• A quiet space for pair discussions
• A flipchart or whiteboard with examples of metaphor and analogy formats
• Optional Starter Metaphor Themes prompt cards

Setup

• Divide delegates into pairs. If there is an odd number, form one group of three where one person acts as observer or facilitator and then rotate.
• On a flipchart or board, write:

You are not giving advice directly. You are telling a fable, a metaphor or an image that speaks to the problem indirectly.

• Give a few spoken examples to inspire creativity:

“You’re like a juggler trying to balance flaming torches in a windstorm. Maybe it’s time to put a few down until the air is calmer.”

“This sounds like you’re building a house on shifting sand; perhaps you need a firmer foundation before decorating the roof.”

• Remind delegates: the goal is not to be clever, but to be helpful. Use imagery that captures a truth gently and wisely.
• Set the structure (8 minutes per round):
  • Person A shares a real work or life challenge (2 minutes)
  • Person B listens without interrupting, then responds using metaphor/story/analogy only (2 minutes)
  • Person A reflects back what meaning they took from the metaphor (2 minutes)
  • Both discuss briefly how metaphor shifted their perspective (2 minutes)
  • Shift roles and repeat.
• If it is difficult for some to come up with the metaphor on the spot and need more thinking time, get Person A and B to tell each other about their real work or life challenges. Then they can sit in isolation to work on a metaphor/story/analogy for the case of their partner. Then after 5 minutes get back together and share their answer one at a time. They can then give feedback to each other.
• After all pairs have exchanged answered and received feedback, bring back everyone together and reflect on their experience.
• Follow with a discussion. Optionally, you can mention a Star Trek episode where the Enterprise encounters a civilisation which communicate only in metaphor (Star Trek: The Next Generation, Darmok, Season 5, Episode 2).
• To help with metaphor creation you can give them a starter prompt such as the following:

Starter Metaphor Themes

• Nature (storms, seasons, rivers, gardens, weather)
• Travel (maps, detours, luggage, bridges, crossroads)
• Construction (bricks, scaffolding, blueprints, foundations)
• Animals (wolves in sheep’s clothing, turtles, bees, birds)
• Sports (racing, falling behind, changing teams, rest days)
• Cooking (too many cooks, missing ingredients, wrong recipe)
• Fables (classic-style short lessons involving characters and symbolic events)

Starting Sentence Examples

“This reminds me of...”

“It’s like when...”

“Imagine a situation where...”

Timing

Explaining the Exercise: 5 minutes

Activity: 16 minutes

Group Feedback: 10 minutes

Discussion

Facilitate a reflective group discussion:

• How did it feel to receive feedback through metaphor?
• Did it help you reflect more deeply or differently than direct advice?
• Was it easier or harder to give metaphorical feedback? Why?
• What made a metaphor land well or miss the mark?
• How could this technique be useful in your leadership or coaching practice?

Soft Skills Training Materials

Browse Full Product Catalogue

About Our Training Materials

Get downloadable training materials

Online Train the Trainer Course:
Core Skills

Learn How to Become the Best Trainer in Your Field

Full Course Details

All Tags

Full Index

Available as paperback and ebook

Download a free comprehensive training package including training guidelines, soft skills training activities, assessment forms and useful training resources that you can use to enhance your courses.

Get Insights - Read Guides and Books - Attend Courses